On Saturday morning, October 4, 2025, a devastating fire engulfed the marshfront home of South Carolina Circuit Court Judge Diane Goodstein in Edisto Beach, upending her life just weeks after a high-profile ruling involving voter data privacy.
Judge Goodstein was out walking her dogs near the shoreline in the gated Jeremy Cay community when flames erupted in her three‐story house at 18 Planters Retreat. The fire is believed to have started shortly before 11:30 a.m. and spread with shocking speed. Witnesses reported seeing thick black smoke and hearing an explosion just before the blaze burst forth.
Inside the home were her husband, Arnold Goodstein, and at least two other relatives — including their son, Arnold Samuel Goodstein II. In a desperate bid to escape, Arnold leapt from the burning house into adjacent marshland. Because the terrain was difficult for first responders, neighbors helped in the rescue effort using ropes and a canoe to reach the injured and bring them to safety.
All three suffered serious injuries. Arnold sustained multiple broken bones in his legs, hips, and feet. His son was also hospitalized, and at least one individual was transferred to the Medical University of South Carolina for advanced care.
At this stage, the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) is investigating the fire. Although the official cause remains undetermined, several signs point to the possibility of an internal explosion or arson. Authorities are examining the site for accelerants, fault in electrical or gas systems, and structural anomalies. The home has been secured for a forensic investigation.
The timing of the fire has drawn attention because it came soon after Judge Goodstein issued a temporary restraining order preventing the South Carolina Election Commission from releasing voter data containing sensitive personal identifiers. Her ruling in that politically charged case generated controversy and sparked debate across the state.
In the days after the fire, reports emerged that Judge Goodstein had previously received threats tied to her judicial work. In response, security has been tightened around her and her family, and SLED’s chief is personally overseeing the inquiry.
The Goodsteins have deep roots in public service. Diane Goodstein, a longtime jurist, and her husband, a former state legislator and Vietnam veteran, have served in legal, civic, and political roles for decades. Their children have also been active in community and legal causes.
The fire has struck the Edisto Island community with shock and sorrow. As investigators work, many are left asking: Was this a tragic accident or a calculated act? Until SLED releases its conclusions, the full truth remains unknown.
